top of page
15.jpg.jpeg

Self-Perception Shapes How We View Our Teammates

Dec 29, 2023
7 min read

Updated: Sep 29

Jealousy can wreck a team from the inside long before anybody outside the locker room realizes there's a problem. It usually doesn't start with some huge blowup either. It starts when one athlete gets the opportunity another athlete wanted, somebody gets more playing time, somebody receives praise from the coach, a freshman starts ahead of an upperclassman, or one player's success begins exposing another player's insecurity. If those feelings aren't dealt with honestly, disappointment can turn into comparison, comparison into resentment, and resentment into behavior that slowly poisons relationships.


Athletes need to understand that feeling disappointed, insecure, or even jealous doesn't automatically make them terrible teammates. Those emotions are human, but what you do with them matters. You can acknowledge jealousy and deal with it, or you can feed it until somebody else's success starts feeling like your failure.


For Christian athletes, Scripture doesn't give us much room to pretend jealousy is harmless. James 3:14 through 16 (ESV) says, “But if you have bitter jealousy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast and be false to the truth. This is not the wisdom that comes down from above, but is earthly, unspiritual, demonic. For where jealousy and selfish ambition exist, there will be disorder and every vile practice.”


That's strong language because jealousy isn't something we're supposed to pet, protect, and justify. We need to recognize it before it starts determining how we treat people.


Recognize What's Really Going On


Sometimes what bothers us about another person has more to do with what's happening inside us than anything they've actually done. If I'm insecure about my role, somebody else's playing time may bother me. If I'm questioning my ability, somebody else's improvement may feel threatening. If I desperately need recognition, hearing the coach praise somebody else can suddenly feel like criticism of me even when nobody said a word about my performance.


That doesn't mean every conflict is projection or that teammates never legitimately behave poorly. Sometimes another person really is selfish, arrogant, disrespectful, or difficult. The point is that we need enough self awareness to ask an uncomfortable question before deciding somebody else is the problem.


What exactly about their success bothers me?


If your teammate getting better makes you angry, that's worth examining. If you can celebrate your friend when they're struggling but suddenly can't stand them when they start succeeding, that's worth examining too. If somebody receiving an opportunity you wanted immediately changes how you treat them, the problem may not be what they received. The problem may be what their opportunity exposed in you.


Build Confidence Without Needing Comparison


One of the best ways to fight jealousy is developing confidence that doesn't require somebody else to be beneath you. There's nothing wrong with wanting to start, earn recognition, become the best player at your position, or compete for opportunities. I want athletes who are hungry enough to fight for those things.


The problem begins when your confidence requires somebody else to fail.


Real confidence doesn't need your teammate to play badly so you can feel good about yourself. You shouldn't need somebody to miss serves, struggle in practice, lose their starting position, or get criticized by the coach before you can feel secure about where you stand.


Romans 12:3 (ESV) tells believers “not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think, but to think with sober judgment.” That isn't a command to think poorly of yourself. It's a call to see yourself accurately. You can recognize your strengths without pretending you don't have weaknesses, and you can acknowledge somebody else's strengths without believing they somehow diminish yours.


Your teammate being talented doesn't make you less talented. Their success doesn't steal your potential, and their opportunity doesn't determine your worth.


Sometimes it should challenge you, though.


If somebody beat you out for a position because they're working harder, preparing better, communicating more effectively, or performing more consistently, don't waste the lesson by turning them into the villain. Learn from what they're doing. Let competition sharpen you instead of making you bitter.


Have the Conversation Before You Create the Story


Teams also get into trouble when athletes stop communicating with each other and start creating stories about each other. Somebody walks past you without saying hello and suddenly they're mad at you. A teammate doesn't celebrate your point enthusiastically enough and now they're jealous. Somebody gets quiet after being taken out of a match and everybody decides they have a terrible attitude.


Sometimes we're responding to entire conversations that never actually happened.


Strong teams need athletes who are willing to communicate directly instead of collecting assumptions, gossiping with three other teammates, and then treating their interpretation like established fact. If there's a legitimate issue, have the conversation. If you're hurt, say you're hurt. If you're confused, ask the question. If you've screwed up, own it.


Ephesians 4:15 (ESV) speaks about “speaking the truth in love,” and both parts matter. Truth without love can become cruelty, while avoiding truth because we're afraid of an uncomfortable conversation isn't love either.


You don't build trust by pretending conflict doesn't exist. You build it by learning how to work through conflict without destroying each other.


Compete With Your Teammates Without Competing Against Your Teammates


I've always liked the concept of “co-opetition,” which combines cooperation and competition. Sports require both because teammates absolutely compete with each other. Pretending otherwise is ridiculous. Two setters may be fighting for one starting position, three outside hitters may be competing for two spots, and everybody wants playing time.


Competition inside a team isn't automatically unhealthy.


The question is whether your competition is making everybody better or whether your insecurity is making the environment worse.


A great teammate can desperately want the starting position and still celebrate when the other person succeeds. You can believe you're capable of playing more and still support the person currently playing ahead of you. You can compete your ass off in practice without secretly hoping your teammate fails during a match.


That's maturity.


Romans 12:15 (ESV) says, “Rejoice with those who rejoice, weep with those who weep.” Rejoicing with somebody becomes a whole lot harder when they just received the exact thing you wanted, which is probably why it's such a good test of what's happening in your heart.


Can you genuinely celebrate a teammate who earned the position you wanted? Can you congratulate somebody who received the award you thought you deserved? Can you encourage the person playing ahead of you while continuing to compete for their spot?


That's where being a good teammate becomes expensive.


Remember What Jersey You're Wearing


Individual goals matter, and I'm never going to tell athletes to stop having them. You should want to improve, earn playing time, achieve personal goals, and become as good as you're capable of becoming, but the moment you join a team, your individual ambition has to learn how to coexist with something bigger than you.


Philippians 2:3 through 4 (ESV) says, “Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others.”


That doesn't mean Christian athletes aren't allowed to compete for positions or pursue individual excellence. Paul isn't writing about athletic competition. He's addressing humility and unity among believers, but the principle should challenge the way Christian athletes carry themselves within a team.


If your team wins and you're miserable because you didn't play, that's something you need to examine. If your teammate has the match of their life and your first reaction is worrying about what that means for your playing time, examine it. If you secretly feel better when the athlete ahead of you struggles, examine that too.


You don't have to lie about wanting more for yourself, but you do need to decide whether you actually love your teammates enough to want good things for them when those good things don't directly benefit you.


That's where jealousy can become something productive if we're willing to confront it instead of hiding it. Jealousy can expose where we're insecure, where we've tied our identity too tightly to our role, where we're comparing ourselves too much, or where selfish ambition has started taking over. What gets exposed can be addressed, and what gets addressed can change.


Coaches have responsibility here too because team culture doesn't become healthy because we put the word “family” on a T shirt. We need to communicate roles honestly, avoid unnecessarily pitting athletes against each other, recognize contributions beyond statistics, address gossip and destructive behavior, and create an environment where athletes understand that competition and support aren't opposites.


We also need to teach athletes that somebody else's success isn't an emergency.


Your teammate getting better can make you better. Their strengths can cover your weaknesses, your strengths can cover theirs, and the person you're competing against in practice may be the same person you desperately need beside you when the match is on the line.


Jealousy tells you there's only enough success for one person, so somebody else has to become smaller for you to become bigger. That's a miserable way to live, and it's an even worse way to build a team.


You don't have to pretend you never feel jealous, disappointed, threatened, or insecure. You do have to decide whether those feelings are going to coach you.


Let them expose what needs work, bring them to God, have the conversations you need to have, keep competing, and keep working. Then learn how to clap just as hard when somebody else succeeds.


You can want the position and still love the person who has it. You can be disappointed for yourself and genuinely happy for your teammate at the same time. You can compete fiercely without becoming bitter, and you can allow somebody else's excellence to challenge you without allowing it to threaten you.


That's the kind of teammate everybody wants standing beside them when things get hard, and becoming that person requires winning some battles inside yourself long before anybody sees what happens on the court.


Self-Perception Shapes How We View Our Teammates


Comments


bottom of page