top of page
15.jpg.jpeg

Evangelism and Coaching

Jun 21, 2024
4 min read

Updated: Sep 29

Christian coaches can find themselves in a difficult position when an athlete has no interest in hearing about Scripture or Christianity. A coach may genuinely want to share the Gospel, but good intentions don't give us permission to force spiritual conversations on someone who doesn't want them. Coaches already hold authority over playing time, roles, opportunities, recommendations, and sometimes scholarships, so we have to be especially careful that an athlete never feels like participating in our faith is part of earning our approval.


Resistance can come from a lot of places. An athlete may follow another religion, have no religious beliefs at all, have questions about Christianity they haven't resolved, or have previous experiences with churches or Christians that left them skeptical. They may also be willing to talk about faith eventually but not with their coach or not at that particular moment. We don't have to agree with an athlete's beliefs to respect their right to hold them, and we shouldn't interpret every boundary as a challenge we're supposed to break through.


That doesn't mean Christian coaches have to hide their faith. There's a major difference between living openly as a Christian and constantly pushing Christianity onto an athlete. Athletes can know what I believe, see me pray, hear me talk about the role faith plays in my life when it's appropriate, and know that I'm available if they ever want to talk. They should also know they're going to receive the same coaching, investment, respect, and opportunities whether they share my beliefs or not.


That distinction matters because evangelism isn't manipulation. If an athlete feels like they have to listen to a religious message because the person delivering it controls their playing time, position, or future, we've created a problem. Faith shouldn't become another test an athlete has to pass to stay in good standing with a coach.


Sometimes the strongest Christian witness a coach has isn't another Bible verse. It's consistency. It's how you respond when an athlete makes a mistake, how you treat the player who isn't helping you win, how you handle officials when you're angry, how you speak about people when they aren't in the room, whether you admit when you're wrong, and whether the Christian values you talk about are still visible when you're frustrated. If I'm preaching grace and treating people without it, my athletes are going to notice the contradiction long before they remember anything I said about Jesus.


That doesn't mean we're trying to behave well enough to trick somebody into a religious conversation either. Caring about athletes can't become a strategy where kindness is offered with an agenda attached. If I tell an athlete I care about them as a person, that care has to remain true even if they never become a Christian. Otherwise, I wasn't really loving them. I was treating the relationship like a conversion project.


When an athlete does become curious about faith, that's when listening becomes incredibly important. Don't assume you know what they're asking or immediately unload everything you know about Christianity. Ask what they believe, what they've experienced, what they're struggling to understand, and what questions they actually have. If they ask something you don't know, there's nothing wrong with saying you don't know and taking the time to find a responsible answer. Christian coaches don't need to pretend to be theologians to be faithful witnesses.


We also have to understand that conversion isn't something a coach produces through persistence. 1 Corinthians 3:6 (ESV) says, “I planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the growth.” That's an important correction for coaches because we're wired to teach, correct, push, repeat, and keep working until somebody gets it. That approach may work when we're fixing footwork or teaching a defensive system, but another person's faith isn't ours to manufacture.


Our responsibility is to represent Christ faithfully, speak truth when we have an appropriate opportunity, answer questions honestly, and respect the person standing in front of us. We can pray for athletes without pressuring them, care about them without trying to control their beliefs, and continue investing in them when they don't respond the way we'd hoped.


There may even be times when an athlete directly tells us they don't want to discuss faith. Respect that boundary. Don't turn every leadership lesson into a disguised sermon or keep looking for another angle because we've convinced ourselves persistence is evangelism. A coach who refuses to hear “no” isn't demonstrating respect, and repeatedly pushing past an athlete's stated boundary can damage both the relationship and the Christian witness we're supposedly trying to protect.


Christian coaches should absolutely live their faith without apology, but we should live it well enough that athletes don't experience Christianity as pressure coming from someone who holds authority over them. Let them see integrity, humility, accountability, patience, compassion, and consistency long before we're worried about whether we've said enough.


Share when the door is open. Answer when questions come. Don't hide what you believe, but don't force your way into a conversation somebody has clearly told you they aren't ready to have.


Sometimes you plant. Sometimes you water. Sometimes your role is simply to live faithfully in front of somebody who may never tell you what they learned from watching you.


God handles the growth.


Evangelism and Coaching

Comments


bottom of page